Share on Social Media

A Chicken Soup Even My Picky Cousin Will Eat

Honestly, I first stumbled onto this Crockpot Marry Me Chicken Soup business by accident. I’d heard of the famous ‘Marry Me Chicken,’ but I was craving soup and, let’s be real, my sink was already full of dishes. So I thought, why not throw all the best bits into my trusty slow cooker and see what happens? (Spoiler: I ended up slurping straight from the ladle before dinner was even served—no shame.) Now every time I make it, something wild always happens, like someone proposing to someone else or my grandma declaring she wants the recipe… after her third bowl. Go figure.

Why This Soup Always Hits the Spot

I make this when it’s cold and gray and I need a bit of a food hug (or when my fridge looks like a vegetable graveyard). My family goes crazy for this because it’s creamy, garlicky, and honest-to-goodness simple. Trust me, if I can manage this after a long Monday, you can too. I used to stress over the exact ingredients—then I realized, as long as you have decent chicken and something resembling sun-dried tomatoes, you’re golden. Oh! And if, like me, you’ve ever been bamboozled by a slow cooker refusing to heat up, don’t panic—it’ll get there, eventually.

What You’ll Need (But Don’t Freak If You’re Missing Something)

3 boneless, skinless chicken breasts (thighs work! Sometimes more tender if you like dark meat. You can even use rotisserie chicken, just add it towards the end.)
1 large onion, diced (No yellow onion? I’ve used red or shallots, didn’t notice much difference honestly.)
4 cloves garlic, minced (I use the stuff in a jar half the time. Purists can look away now.)
1/2 cup sun-dried tomatoes in oil, chopped (Drain them a tad, but don’t be fussy. Totally fine to sub in roasted red peppers when you’re out.)
4 cups chicken broth (or stock—my grandmother always insisted on homemade, but carton works fine for us mortals.)
1 cup heavy cream (Half-and-half is okay if you want it a bit lighter. I tried oat milk once, but it got weird.)
1/2 cup grated Parmesan (I’ve even done a cheapo pre-shredded blend and it was still delicious.)
1 teaspoon dried Italian herbs (or just oregano and basil if that’s all you’ve got.)
2 cups baby spinach (I’ve chucked in kale and it still tastes grand)
Salt & pepper (as you like. I always taste at the end.)
2 tablespoons olive oil
Pasta (optional): Some folks like ditalini or orzo stirred in. When I’m feeling carby, I do this. Totally your call!

How I Actually Make This (A Play-by-Play)

Drizzle olive oil into your slow cooker (honestly, I just splash it in). Add diced onion and garlic. If you want, sauté these first in a skillet, but most days, I just toss them in raw—no big deal.
Add chicken breasts, sun-dried tomatoes, Italian herbs, and chicken broth. Give it a stir (if you can be bothered). Sometimes, I push the chicken under so it’s mostly covered, but if it pokes out a little—meh—it’ll still cook.
Cover and cook on low for about 6-7 hours, or high for 3-4. When I’m in a rush, I’ll crank it to high, but honestly, it tastes richer when it goes low and slow. This is where I usually wander off and remember I left the laundry in the washer.
Once the chicken is cooked enough that it basically falls apart if you look at it, fish it out (careful—it’s hotter than you think). Shred with two forks (or your hands if you’re feeling wild). Then plop it back in.
Stir in cream and Parmesan. If you’re adding pasta, toss it in now. Let it cook another 20-30 minutes until the pasta’s done (I start poking it with a fork around 18 minutes—no perfection here).
Finally, stir in the spinach. It’ll wilt down in minutes (looks like way too much at first, but trust me—just keep swishing).
Taste for salt and pepper. Sometimes I go heavy on black pepper for a little kick.

Notes from My Not-So-Perfect Kitchen

I’ve accidentally left this on ‘keep warm’ overnight, and honestly, it thickens but still tastes fine the next day.
Chicken thighs give it a richer flavor, but if I’m broke, I use whatever’s on sale.
Don’t worry if your sun-dried tomatoes are a little chewy—they’ll soften up eventually (promise).

Variations I’ve Played With (And a Mess-Up)

No Dairy: Swapped the cream for coconut milk—it’s… interesting. Actually, not my favorite, but pretty good if you love coconut.
Mexican-ish: Left out the Italian herbs and sun-dried tomatoes, used a can of fire-roasted tomatoes and added chili powder. Completely different, but surprisingly tasty.
Dud Alert: Tried chickpeas instead of chicken once for my veggie friend. It just made it taste like… chickpeas in broth. Not my best idea.

Do You Really Need Fancy Equipment?

I use a 6-quart Crockpot but, honestly, any slow cooker that holds all your ingredients works. If you’re crockpot-less, you can simmer this gently on the stove; as long as you keep the heat low and give it the odd stir, you’ll get there in the end. One time, I tried using a Dutch oven in the oven—took a bit longer, but was still tasty in the finish.

How to Store (A.K.A. If You Have Leftovers)

Let it cool, then stick in airtight containers; fridge for up to 3 days. Some folks say it’s great frozen, but cream soups can separate a bit (I give it a vigorous whisk after thawing—works for me). Truthfully, this rarely survives the first night for me, but hey, your mileage may vary.

Serving This Soup—Make It Yours

I love it with crusty sourdough, but my sister dunks Ritz crackers in hers (no accounting for taste). Sometimes we sprinkle on extra Parmesan and a handful of fresh basil if we’ve got it. On lazy weekends, I dish it up in my biggest mug and eat it curled up in front of a movie. Somehow it tastes even better that way.

Pro Tips (AKA My Lesson the Hard Way)

I once tried throwing in all the cheese at the beginning; it just clumped up oddly. Now I always add Parmesan near the end.
Don’t rush the chicken—if it’s not fully shreddable, let it go another half hour. Tough chicken is a crime against comfort food, if you ask me.
If using pasta, don’t overdo it—seriously, a handful goes a long way. One time I added a cup of orzo and it soaked up literally everything. Oops.

Questions I’ve Actually Been Asked

Do I have to use sun-dried tomatoes? Nope! You can sub in roasted peppers, fresh tomatoes (just toss them in), or even skip it. The soup forgives.
Can I make this ahead? Yes, and I think it tastes better the next day, though you may need a splash of broth when reheating.
Can I freeze it? Sure, though the cream gets a little funky. Actually, stir like mad after thawing—should come back together.
Is it really as good as everyone says? Well, my cousin tried to take some home in an old yogurt tub, so that’s something! And if you’re doubting, check out Ambitious Kitchen’s version—she makes it look so pretty. Oh, and here’s a step-by-step guide from Delish I like for visuals.
Is this super kid-friendly? My niece eats two bowls. But every kid is different—the sun-dried tomatoes might get the side eye at first.
What if I hate spinach? Honestly? Just leave it out. Or use kale, or nothing. Soup’s not going to file a complaint.