Let Me Tell You About the Time I Fell in Love with Shrimp Salad
Okay, so picture this: It’s summer in Manhattan, I’m sweating buckets and duck into a classic deli just to cool off for five minutes. And that’s when I spot it—this gorgeous, creamy shrimp salad piled high in the case. I order a scoop on rye toast, sit by the window, and, no kidding, I still think about that first bite years later. (I may have gotten a little emotional; I blame the heat.) And ever since, I’ve been on a mission to recreate that deli magic at home. Spoiler alert: after a few flops—like that one time I used way too much celery—I’ve worked out a version that’s not half bad. Actually, I think it’s pretty great.
Why You’ll Love This (Or At Least Why I Do)
I make this when I want to pretend I’m back in NYC or just want something quick but feels special—brunch with my cousin, lazy Sunday lunches, even picnics where I inevitably forget a fork. My family goes bananas for this because it’s creamy but not gloopy, bright but still hearty. Sometimes I’ll confess: the shrimp is just an excuse for all that dill. Oh, and if you’re not a fan of mayo, don’t run away yet—I’ve got a sneaky swap below. (Trust me, I was skeptical about yogurt at first too.)
Gather Your Ingredients (No Judgement If You Improvise)
- 450g (about 1 lb) cooked shrimp, peeled & deveined
(I sometimes buy them pre-cooked when I’m short on time—no shame in that game. My aunt swears by the little pink ones, but honestly any size works as long as you’re not fussed about tradition.) - 1/2 cup good mayo (Honestly, any brand is fine; I usually grab Hellmann’s, but the generic stuff works too.)
- 2 tbsp sour cream (Or swap for Greek yogurt if you want to lighten it up. I do this if I’m feeling virtuous—rare.)
- 1 celery stalk, finely chopped (In a pinch, I’ve grated carrot instead. It’s not strictly deli, but no one complained.)
- 2 tbsp red onion, finely diced (Shallots work in a pinch. I tried white onion once… let’s just say it was, uh, assertive.)
- Juice of 1/2 lemon
- 1 tbsp fresh dill, chopped (Dried works if you must, but double up to get that punch.)
- Salt & pepper (Just a pinch, taste as you go!)
- Optional: 1 tsp Dijon mustard, pinch of Old Bay, or a tiny bit of chopped capers for brininess.
How I Actually Make It (With a Few Honest Moments)
- Chop your shrimp into bite-sized pieces. Sometimes I leave a few whole for drama. Toss into a big bowl.
- Add your celery & onion. This is where I usually sneak a bite of shrimp—call it quality control.
- Mix up the sauce: In a smaller bowl, stir together mayo, sour cream (or yogurt), lemon juice, and dill. Add Dijon if you’re feeling fancy. At this stage, it can look a bit odd—don’t worry, it comes together, promise.
- Combine it all: Pour the dressing over the shrimp mixture. Fold gently (don’t mash it, unless you prefer shrimp paste—no judgment, but why?).
- Season with salt & pepper. I tend to go a little heavy on the black pepper, but that’s just me. Taste, adjust, taste again.
- Chill for at least 30 min. I know, waiting is the worst, but trust me—the flavors just meld together and it’s worth it.
A Few Things I Learned the Hard Way
- If you use bottled lemon juice, it’ll taste a bit flat. But, in a pinch, it’s still good enough for a Tuesday.
- Once, I tried using those tiny frozen salad shrimp without thawing—don’t do that unless you like shrimp ice lollies.
- It’s so much better after a night in the fridge. If you can wait that long. I rarely do.
Variations I’ve Tried (Some Better Than Others)
- Lobster Swap: Fancy pants? Use lobster instead of shrimp—splurgy but amazing.
- Herb Overload: Parsley, tarragon, or even a bit of chive. I once went overboard and it tasted like a lawn, so maybe just a sprinkle.
- No Mayo: All Greek yogurt with a splash of olive oil. Lighter, tangier, not as deli-ish but not bad at all.
- Spicy: Tiny squirt of sriracha or a shake of cayenne if you like it hot. (Maybe too hot—you’ve been warned.)
What You Really Need (And What You Can Skip)
- Mixing bowls: At least two. If you only have one, just wipe it out between steps—I’ve done it loads of times.
- Sharp knife: Makes the chopping less of a slog. But honestly, I’ve used a bread knife in a pinch.
- Optional: A microplane for zesting if you want to really up the lemony hit. If not, just skip it.
How to Store It (If It Lasts That Long)
Pop any leftovers in an airtight container in the fridge—they’ll last about 2 days. Though honestly, in my house it never lasts more than a day! If you’re bringing it to a picnic, nestle it in with an ice pack. Warm shrimp salad is, um, not my thing.
How I Like to Serve It (Feel Free to Steal My Traditions)
- On toasted rye (classic!) with a few lettuce leaves underneath—just tastes nostalgic to me.
- Stuffed in a pita, with cucumber slices and an extra squeeze of lemon.
- Or, if I’m being fancy, on little endive leaves for a party snack. My cousin calls these ‘shrimp canoes’—I have no idea why but it stuck.
If I Had to Give You One Pro Tip…
I once tried rushing the chilling step and regretted it because the flavors just didn’t mingle—it was like everyone showed up to the party and stood in separate corners. So, really, give it at least half an hour in the fridge. Longer is even better, but who am I kidding, who waits?
Your Burning Questions (Yes, I Really Got Asked These)
- Can I use frozen shrimp? Totally! Just make sure you thaw and dry them well. Wet shrimp salad? Not great; learned that the hard way.
- What if I hate dill? Skip it! Try parsley or even a little basil. Or just leave it plain. It’s your salad.
- My shrimp turned rubbery—what did I do? Probably overcooked them. Buy pre-cooked, or cook until just pink. Actually, I find steaming works best.
- Is this gluten-free? It should be, as long as your mayo and extras are. But check your labels, just to be safe.
Oh, and if you want to nerd out on seafood, I use this Serious Eats shrimp guide all the time, and for good-quality mayo, Bon Appétit’s best mayonnaise taste test was an eye-opener. Not sponsored, just sharing what helps.
Well, now that I’ve rambled on, I’m suddenly starving. Hope you enjoy this as much as I do—and if you find a new tweak or secret ingredient, let me know! (Unless it’s raisins. Please, no raisins.)
Ingredients
- 1 pound cooked large shrimp, peeled and deveined
- 1/2 cup mayonnaise
- 2 tablespoons sour cream
- 1 tablespoon fresh lemon juice
- 1 teaspoon Dijon mustard
- 1/2 cup celery, finely diced
- 2 tablespoons red onion, finely chopped
- 2 tablespoons fresh dill, chopped
- Salt and black pepper to taste
Instructions
-
1In a large bowl, whisk together mayonnaise, sour cream, lemon juice, and Dijon mustard until smooth.
-
2Add the cooked shrimp, celery, red onion, and fresh dill to the bowl.
-
3Gently toss all ingredients until the shrimp are well coated with the dressing.
-
4Season with salt and black pepper to taste.
-
5Cover and refrigerate for at least 15 minutes before serving to allow flavors to meld.
-
6Serve chilled, garnished with extra dill if desired.
Approximate Information for One Serving
Nutrition Disclaimers
Number of total servings shown is approximate. Actual number of servings will depend on your preferred portion sizes.
Nutritional values shown are general guidelines and reflect information for 1 serving using the ingredients listed, not including any optional ingredients. Actual macros may vary slightly depending on specific brands and types of ingredients used.
To determine the weight of one serving, prepare the recipe as instructed. Weigh the finished recipe, then divide the weight of the finished recipe (not including the weight of the container the food is in) by the desired number of servings. Result will be the weight of one serving.
Did you make this recipe?
Please consider Pinning it!!
